An Open Letter To West Philly
This email was sent to a number of radical Philadelphia listservs by a member of The Defenestrator, a local anarchist newspaper. The author of this letter is not a member of their collective. I’ve met him personally and from what I understand he has been working as a community organizer in this city for a long, long time.
I have reposted this on ARTNOISE because, as an outlet that primarily serves the city’s “radical artistic community,” I felt that his words might be particularly relevant to the experience of much of our audience. While this might not be how I would frame all of these issues, I absolutely agree with what I understand his larger point here to be.
White West Philly radicals often pride ourselves on our political commitments and our appreciation of “the community.” Time after time, I think that we prove our politics to be hollow or that our commitment to community extends only as far as our own privileged little subcultural enclaves.
By and large, we are not working to defend our neighbors. By and large, we are not working to organize ourselves as a force that can be an ally to other local residents with more history in the neighborhoods we consider to be “ours.” Really, on a lot of fronts, we are not doing anything… except for maybe putting on our shows, socializing, being hip.
I take his letter as a firm kick in the ass. Privileged white folks of any political stripe should not move into historically black neighborhoods unless they are willing to be accountable to the life, the past, the present, and the future of those neighborhoods. And for me, that means doing work, real work. That means real work to defend our neighbors from foreclosure, real work to fight development schemes don’t give a shit about the real lives of people, real work to know and talk with our neighbors, and real work to put control over our communities into all of our hands.
That’s the real price tag on cheap rent in West Philly. And I think it’s more than time for us to pay up. - germ ross
By A Concerned Relation
I got a email invite last week for the offices of the State representative network. I stopped by and slide down to Clark park as well, here is some thoughts.
So, now that the brew pub is open at 50th and baltimore it had occured to me that maybe now was the right time to write this letter. When you go and sit around all day outside the satellite coffee shop, do you ever think about your role in gentrification? I cannot help but ask this question because sometimes I pass by and I see what to my eye looks like a white settler occupation beachhead down there across from cedar park, with an increasing number of white homeowners within a one block radius and perhaps more disturbingly, Penn students/employees buying houses up to 52nd street with school subsidies.
I remember a time not that long ago when it seemed like there was a conversation going on in West Philly about gentrification and how to organize against what was about to go down… and then people seemed to stop being engaged, maybe they got busy or something. Well, while you were having fun and going to dance parties, guess what happened? THERES A BREW PUB AT 50th and Baltimore, and a YOGA STUDIO and a COFFEE SHOP. HELLO.
Now I am not one to argue that everything is black and white and that those things plus a bunch of white folks moving into a neighborhood simply equals gentrification, but in this case its really hard to see it as anything else. I suppose partly because nobody seems to give a shit and ya’ll are going on with your hipster lifestyles. I mean christ, the brew pub is open and nobody broke the fucking windows yet. It was bad enough when trader joes got a compactor and nobody sabotaged it. IS THIS WEST PHILLY OR WHAT? Aren’t ya’ll supposed to be anarchists or something? If shit gets to a certain point don’t you need to take direct action if you failed to engage in the process that could have stopped it? A bunch of you are white homeowners, you could have been at the neighborhood meetings, you could have stopped that shit. And what’s with letting these snot-nosed hipster fucks move into the neighborhood so they can look cool? Are you really just going to accept this manifest destiny bullshit or are you going to take responsibility for where you live and for what you have helped happen. Silence equals consent remember? People fight and organize around gentrification in places like New York, Miami and San Francisco and win their battles against much fiercer odds. Penn is not an unstoppable juggernaught and neither are developers, ya’ll just gotta get down with the neighborhood and start building some people power, have concrete demands, know where to put pressure and have an alternate plan. Organizing is not rocket science, and at a certain point white guilt builds into not doing anything and playing a part in the white agenda - don’t get caught up in that shit, its just as bad as not acknowledging your privilege in the first place, in fact its worse. Are you just turning into liberals as you get older?
Maybe if ya’ll got your act together in the neighborhood we could start working on city-wide issues again, like how the cops have declared open season on black folks the past couple years, or about how they’re building prisons and condos while there’s homeless folks on the streets and people are hungry and there’s no health care and there’s no jobs. If you were a bunch of socialists you would have done something by now and there would be an organization and a program. This is a kick in the butt. Don’t get so comfortable in your urban cool lifestyles, push yourselves, get back into politics and be part of organizing and action or move out - we don’t need you if your just going to play your part in the developer agenda.
…what does the rich versus poor really mean? psychologically it means you gotta pick your team. - KRS-ONE
A note to our friends and neighbors in this great city…
[This article was written for ARTNOISE by the Afropick organizing crew, with some minor editing on our part.
Mischief Brew
ARTNOISE WEBZINE NOW HAS A FUCKING MYSPACE!
The Microscopic Septet
Emilyn Brodsky
Circles
The Cutest Puppy In The World
